Consumer Eye Care
If you wear contact lenses, you've almost certainly seen 1-800 Contacts ads. They promise convenience, low prices, and even free online vision exams. As an optometrist, I want to give you the full picture — because what they don't advertise is a documented record of anticompetitive behavior, regulatory violations, and practices that put their profits above your eye health.
1-800 Contacts is a real company — but it has been found by the Federal Trade Commission to engage in practices that harm consumers, suppress competition, and undermine the standard of care that contact lens wearers deserve. Here's what the record shows.
This isn't opinion — it's federal regulatory action. The FTC found that 1-800 Contacts entered into anticompetitive agreements with rival online contact lens sellers. These agreements prevented competitors from bidding on search engine ads that would have shown consumers that identical lenses were available at lower prices elsewhere.
In plain terms: 1-800 Contacts paid competitors to stay out of their search results so you couldn't easily find out you were overpaying. The FTC ruled this violated Section 5 of the FTC Act and ordered them to cease and desist. The company appealed, but the core finding — that they worked to suppress price competition — stands in the public record.
This matters to you directly. If you've been ordering from 1-800 Contacts assuming you were getting the best deal, the FTC's finding suggests you may not have been — because competitors who might have offered lower prices were blocked from telling you so.
During COVID-19, 1-800 Contacts ran messaging on their website that read: "Take our Online Vision Exam for Free While Eye Care Providers are Closed."
This statement was misleading. Eye care providers were not universally closed — many were open for urgent and essential care, and all were actively working to serve patients safely. The implication that online exams were the only option was false, and it was designed to drive patients to their app rather than to their doctors.
The American Optometric Association (AOA) formally demanded they remove this language. 1-800 Contacts complied — but only after the intervention. They did not remove it voluntarily.
This is perhaps the most important clinical point I can make as an optometrist: an online vision test is not a comprehensive eye exam. It never has been, and no technology currently makes it one.
What an online vision test can do is generate a refraction — a rough estimate of your glasses or contact lens power based on how well you read a digital chart. What it cannot do is any of the following:
Contact lenses are FDA-classified medical devices. They rest directly on your cornea. Fitting them without a proper clinical evaluation — including slit-lamp examination — is not just substandard care. In patients with undetected corneal conditions or dry eye disease, it can cause real harm: corneal scarring, chronic infection, and in severe cases, vision loss.
A note on the Contact Lens Rule: Federal law requires that anyone prescribing contact lenses must provide the patient with a copy of their prescription and obtain verified confirmation before releasing lenses. The AOA reported that 1-800 Contacts' mobile app was not obtaining proper affirmative consent from patients before sending electronic prescriptions — a violation of the Contact Lens Rule. The FTC investigated following the AOA's report.
Contact lens shortages are a real supply chain issue in the industry. When lenses are backordered, patients wait. What's frustrating about 1-800 Contacts' position as the nation's largest online contact lens retailer is that their scale means they can hold significant inventory — inventory that local practices and smaller retailers cannot access for their own patients in need.
This is a less-discussed consequence of market consolidation: when one company dominates a supply chain, the friction it creates ripples outward to every other patient and provider in that system.
I know this sounds self-serving coming from an optometrist. But the clinical reality is non-negotiable: contact lens wearers need annual comprehensive exams. Not because the law requires it (though it does — contact lens prescriptions expire). Because your eyes change. Because early pathology is silent. Because the cornea you fitted lenses on three years ago may not be the same cornea you have today.
At Harnos Optometry, every contact lens patient receives a comprehensive dilated exam, tear film assessment, and contact lens fit evaluation — not a chart test on a phone screen.
Federal law gives you the right to:
Your doctor cannot withhold your prescription or require you to buy lenses from them as a condition of receiving it. If they do, that's a violation you can report to the FTC.
There are legitimate online contact lens retailers who compete fairly, price transparently, and comply with the Contact Lens Rule. 1-800 Contacts is not the only option — and based on the FTC's findings, may not have been giving you the best price. Compare prices across multiple licensed retailers, and make sure any seller verifies your prescription with your doctor before shipping.
1-800 Contacts built a massive business on convenience — and convenience is genuinely valuable. But convenience should not come at the cost of your eye health, your consumer rights, or fair pricing. The FTC's action against them is not a minor administrative dispute. It reflects a pattern of placing market dominance above the interests of the patients and consumers they serve.
Your eyes deserve better than a phone screen test and a company with a documented record of anticompetitive conduct. They deserve an actual doctor, an actual exam, and an actual relationship with someone who will be there when something changes.
We're accepting new patients at Harnos Optometry in New Paltz. If you have questions about your contact lens prescription, your eye health, or anything in this post — call us, text us, or book online. We're happy to talk.
Is 1-800 Contacts legit?
1-800 Contacts is a real, operating company. However, the Federal Trade Commission found it guilty of anticompetitive agreements with rival sellers designed to suppress price competition. They have also faced regulatory action related to the Contact Lens Rule. "Legit" in the sense of existing — yes. "Legit" in the sense of trustworthy and ethical — that's more complicated.
Can I use 1-800 Contacts' online eye exam instead of seeing a doctor?
No — and this is important. An online vision test generates a rough refraction estimate. It cannot examine your eye health, screen for glaucoma, detect retinal disease, evaluate your tear film, or assess your cornea. A comprehensive in-person eye exam does all of these things. Skipping it to save time or money is a false economy when the alternative is undetected eye disease.
Why did the FTC go after 1-800 Contacts?
The FTC found that 1-800 Contacts entered into agreements with competing online contact lens retailers that prevented those competitors from bidding on search ads — suppressing consumer awareness of lower prices available elsewhere. This was found to violate Section 5 of the FTC Act, which prohibits unfair methods of competition.
Do I have to buy my contact lenses from my eye doctor?
No. Under the federal Contact Lens Rule, you have the right to receive your prescription from your doctor and purchase lenses from any licensed seller you choose. Your doctor must provide your prescription at no additional charge after your exam and fitting. You are not obligated to buy from them.
Where can I get contact lenses in New Paltz, NY?
Harnos Optometry at 222 Main Street in New Paltz fits and supplies contact lenses for all prescription types — including daily disposables, monthly lenses, toric lenses for astigmatism, multifocals, and specialty lenses including sclerals and Ortho-K. Call (845) 255-4696 or book online.
Sources: FTC v. 1-800 Contacts (2016) · AOA Demands 1-800 Contacts Change Misleading Message
Comprehensive contact lens exams, expert fitting, and genuine care — not a phone screen test.
222 Main Street · New Paltz, NY 12561 · (845) 255-4696
Book an Appointment Call Us