Mon to Thu 9 AM to 5 PM, Fri 8 AM to 3 PM

Consumer eye care. July 2023, by Dr. Brandon Harnos

What to Know Before Ordering Contacts From 1-800 Contacts

If you wear contact lenses, you've almost certainly seen 1-800 Contacts ads promising convenience, low prices, and free online vision exams. As an optometrist, I want to give you some context they don't put in the ads, particularly around what an online vision test can and can't do for your eye health, and what your rights are as a patient.

Book a contact lens exam Call or text (845) 255-4696

Correction and Retraction

Per a cease and desist letter received from an attorney representing 1-800 Contacts, we are correcting the following.

An earlier version of this article stated that the Federal Trade Commission had found 1-800 Contacts liable for anticompetitive conduct related to certain trademark settlement agreements with competing online contact lens retailers. That statement was inaccurate.

The FTC's order was vacated by the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in 1-800 Contacts, Inc. v. Federal Trade Commission, 1 F.4th 102 (2d Cir. 2021). As a result of that decision, there is no operative federal finding of liability against 1-800 Contacts arising from that matter. We regret the error and have corrected the article accordingly.

Pandemic-Era Messaging That Discouraged Patients From Seeing Their Doctor

During COVID-19, 1-800 Contacts' website carried messaging that read: "Take our Online Vision Exam for Free While Eye Care Providers are Closed." That statement was misleading. Eye care providers were not universally closed. Many practices were open for urgent and essential care throughout the pandemic. The American Optometric Association formally objected to the language in an October 2020 letter, and 1-800 Contacts confirmed it modified the wording shortly after.

Their Online Eye Exam Is Not a Comprehensive Eye Exam

This is the most important clinical point I can make. An online vision test is not a comprehensive eye exam, and no current technology makes it one.

What an online vision test can do is generate a rough refraction estimate based on how well you read a digital chart. What it cannot do:

  • Examine the health of your cornea, retina, or optic nerve
  • Measure intraocular pressure, a key glaucoma screen
  • Detect early signs of diabetic retinopathy, macular degeneration, or retinal tears
  • Evaluate your tear film to determine the right contact lens for your eye
  • Assess eye alignment, binocular vision, or focusing function
  • Identify conditions like keratoconus that make standard contact lenses inappropriate

Contact lenses are FDA regulated medical devices that rest directly on the cornea. Fitting them without a proper clinical evaluation, including a slit lamp exam, is substandard care. In patients with undetected corneal conditions or dry eye disease, it can lead to corneal scarring, chronic infection, or in severe cases vision loss.

The AOA also reported in 2020 that 1-800 Contacts' mobile app was not obtaining proper verified affirmative consent before sending electronic prescriptions, as required under the Contact Lens Rule. Following that report, 1-800 Contacts made corrective changes to its app.

They Rely on Automated Calls You May Never Actually Hear

Federal law allows online sellers to verify a prescription by placing an automated call to your doctor's office. If the office doesn't respond within eight business hours, the prescription is treated as verified whether or not anyone actually reviewed it. This is legal, it's called passive verification, and it's built into the Contact Lens Rule on purpose.

In practice, these calls often arrive after hours, as a recorded message left with no one there to catch an error in real time. Our office regularly receives these automated verification calls from 1-800 Contacts while we're closed. A national AOA survey of optometrists found this is common industry wide: 89 percent of respondents had received verification calls for invalid prescriptions, 54 percent for the wrong prescription, and 43 percent for a call about someone who wasn't even their patient.

None of this means the seller is doing anything illegal. It means the system depends on your doctor catching a mistake within an eight hour window, often overnight or over a weekend, before lenses ship. If your prescription has changed recently or you're not sure it's current, it's worth confirming with your doctor directly before ordering, rather than assuming an automated call was reviewed by a real person.

What You Should Do Instead

See your eye doctor every year, without exception. Contact lens wearers need annual comprehensive exams, not because the law technically requires it (though prescriptions do expire), but because your eyes change and early disease is often silent. At Harnos Optometry, every contact lens patient gets a comprehensive dilated exam, tear film assessment, and contact lens fit evaluation, not a chart test on a phone screen.

Know your rights under the Contact Lens Rule. Federal law gives you the right to receive your prescription automatically and at no extra charge after your fitting, to buy lenses from any seller you choose, and to have your prescription verified before any seller fills it. Your doctor cannot condition giving you your prescription on buying lenses from them.

If you buy online, buy smart. There are legitimate online retailers that compete fairly and comply with the Contact Lens Rule. Compare prices across licensed sellers and confirm they verify your prescription with your doctor before shipping.

The Bottom Line

Convenience is genuinely valuable, but it shouldn't come at the cost of your eye health. Your eyes deserve an actual exam and an actual relationship with a doctor who will be there when something changes.

We're accepting new patients at Harnos Optometry in New Paltz. If you have questions about your contact lens prescription or your eye health, call us, text us, or book online.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use an online eye exam instead of seeing a doctor?

No. An online vision test generates a rough refraction estimate. It cannot examine your eye health, screen for glaucoma, detect retinal disease, evaluate your tear film, or assess your cornea. A comprehensive in person exam does all of these things.

Do I have to buy my contact lenses from my eye doctor?

No. Under the federal Contact Lens Rule, you have the right to receive your prescription from your doctor and buy lenses from any licensed seller you choose.

Where can I get contact lenses in New Paltz, NY?

Harnos Optometry at 222 Main Street fits and supplies contact lenses for all prescription types, including daily disposables, monthly lenses, toric lenses, multifocals, and specialty lenses including sclerals and Ortho K. Call (845) 255-4696 or book online.

Sources: 1-800 Contacts, Inc. v. FTC, 1 F.4th 102 (2d Cir. 2021) · AOA Demands 1-800 Contacts Change Misleading Message · AOA Health Policy Institute survey on prescription verification calls

Ready when you are.

Book online any time, or call or text us during office hours.

Book a contact lens exam Call or text (845) 255-4696